Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Budget 2009

Sensex may have crashed 600 points after the announcement of the budget, but I still found the budget very responsible although it has fair share of negative policy decisions too .


1. Government high degree of spending on rural and poor India clearly signals the accountability to the people of the country. They are fulfilling the promises made in the general elections.

2. Infrastructure spending will give boost to the manufacturing industry which is facing trouble due to recession. It will also have increased multiplier effect and will boost the overall economy.

3. Increasing MAT to improve the tax revenues from the company which are avoiding tax due to tax incentives given to them. If we see companies like TCS, INFY, they have established themselves well and don’t really need any tax breaks further. Ideally there should be a limit set on net profits and the time company crosses the limit, it should be taxed as a normal company.

4. Boost to agriculture sector in the form of 7% loan will improve the rural economy further, it will improve the purchasing power of almost 650 million Indians.


1. No announcement of disinvestment in both loss and profit making companies is really shocking news. When the country is sitting on huge fiscal deficit and borrowing nearly 34% of the money used for spending, disinvestment could have been a trump card solution which is missed.

2. Imposition of Fringe Benefit Tax was a smart move by the earlier government, by abolishing it tax revenues will be reduced as companies will start paying its employees in the form of benefits and perks to reduce their tax load. This may also increase the fiscal deficit even further.

3. Reducing duties on Plasma TV, Mobile Phones and imported Car - This may be one of the decisions for the galleries, but it really doesn’t help the rising fiscal deficit of the country.

I think the major issue of this budget is clearly the lack of fiscal management by the finance ministry, increased borrowing by the government will cause following effects: -

1. Sovereign Ratings: - Increase fiscal deficit to more than 6%, it may also affect our sovereign ratings and increase the cost of borrowing by the government and the institutions.

2. Crowding out Effect: - Government is borrowing almost 34% of the expenditure from the markets. It will reduce the options for the private sector to get easy funding as it will be competing against the government to secure funds.

3. High Interest Burden: - Around 19% of the budgetary expenditure goes in just paying the interest on the loans taken by the government. High interest burden and increased borrowings is a negative sign for the growth targets of the country.


Rishabh Makrand said...

Ye saab to likh diya.. main bat likhi hi nahi... ki apne kaam ki chizen saab aur mahngi ho gayi hai.. aur unko kharidne ki takat kam ho gayi hai...
angreji me bole to purchasing power gone down...

gary said...

We need to see a lot more infrastructure growth. Wider highways and speedy transportation. Waiving fees should be replaced with linking rivers to manage floods and draught. Abolish Indus water treaty to get more fresh water for our citizens. We should not have any treaties with failed states. Develop tourism industry with a safer n cleaner India. It would earn foreign currency along with attracting local employment.

Right now India is riding on the IT wave, its not gonna last forever. Lets get back to basics with the time we have.

Ankit said...

:-) Quite refreshing Ideas :-)